I want to thank everyone who stopped by Thursday to see my external flaws (or at least some of them).
ASM's idea, along with an abundance of support from both those who participated, and those who visited, made for quite an emotional Thursday in
HNT-land. For me, the timing couldn't have been better.
You see, I'm having a bit of a love/hate relationship with
HNT right now. I enjoy the creativity - attempting to capture the emotions and the feelings of the moment with nothing more than a $125 digital camera, some free photo editing software and
me. Being creative brings me great joy and feelings of pride and accomplishment. I had been neglecting my passion for creativity, and
HNT gave me an outlet with the added bonus of some very positive feedback.
18 months later, and a short two week break from
HNT, I find that I am really having a difficult time with the perceived and/or manufactured competition that is clearly visible in
HNT. There are a handful of
bloggers (four that I can name off the top of my head) who post their favorite
HNT's for the week. Appearing on one of these lists is a
huge honor
especially if it's the right list but it also, in my oh-so-very-humble opinion, fosters a sense of competition and preference between participants. I'm not saying this is true for all who participate, but definitely for some (read that as
me). I'd be surprised if I am the only one who has ever felt this way, and even more surprised if anyone else actually admits to it.
I don't want this to come across as me badmouthing anyone who publishes a favorite
HNT's post every week. One of these
bloggers - whose list is quite well known - is one of my favorite reads each and every day, including the day favorites are posted. Although I've never asked, my guess is that publishing a list of favorite
HNT-
ers is done entirely out of admiration for those who do
HNT well ... "well" in the opinion of the blogger publishing the list. Really no different than having a blog-roll on your side bar. But there is a downside too.
There are some
HNT-
ers who have never appeared in one of these "favorites" lists, and never will. Not because they aren't "playing"
HNT well. Not because they aren't abiding by the
HNT guidelines. Not even because their photography isn't wonderful. No, they won't make a favorites list because their style of
HNT is not consistent with the type of blog that publishes a favorites lists, or maybe because they are male (there is a significant gender bias in
HNT). I find that ... well ...
bothersome.
As
bloggers, we are all out here for encouragement and validation - among other things - whether we participate in
HNT or not. Yet frequently I see 50+ comments on a female
HNT that is sensual, erotic and/or just plain in-your-face naked. The well thought out, creative
HNT that shows nothing more than what one might see at a grocery store? That
HNT-er is lucky to get 3 comments. I don't care what anyone says,
HNT-
ers, although a supportive community, can be a cliquey, fickle and hypocritical bunch too ... and I've been right there with them.
Sure, I do the retro
HNT on the first Thursday of the month - a self imposed reality check of sorts - and I've even had one other
HNT-er regularly join me on that venture, but I've also been far too caught up in the "competition" to be a favorite, pushing my "limits of comfort" in hopes of making a list. I think there are many
HNT-
ers who participate, in part, to help overcome low self-esteem. I certainly can't be the only one, but when it starts being more stressful than fun - more competitive than creative - is it really meeting the intent of
HNT? I can only decide that for myself.
I often refer back to this specific
HNT guideline (from
Osbasso's site):
It's very important to not be dissing other's submissions! We're all going to have half-hearted entries from time to time. None of us is better than the other. One the other hand, it's completely acceptable to heap praise upon those that deserve it! [emphasis mine]
Am I dissing an
HNT submission by not commenting? Am I looking at it and thinking "
EGADS! What the hell were they thinking?" but just quickly closing the browser window so as not to be one of
those people? Is a favorites list nothing more than "heaping praise" on those who
deserve it (I won't even get in to how much that word
deserve bothers me) or is it encouraging others to participate in
HNT in a certain way? I don't know.
What I do know is that I was in tears (literally) after posting my
HNT this week. It sat on my blog for over an hour before the first comment was posted, and that was from
Osbasso (in other words, it felt like a charity comment). I found myself so completely wrapped up in concerns surrounding what others thought that I had no pride - no appreciation - for the creative work I'd done. I knew the pic of my "flaws" wouldn't make
anyones favorite list - it just didn't meet the criteria - and that bothered me too (but I did check Friday morning, hoping maybe I was wrong).
Is all of this the "fault" of those who publish
HNT favorites lists? Of course not. Are people so hung up on their blog numbers that they'll do anything to increase them? Do
HNT-
ers base their self-worth on the number of comments they get? I can only answer these questions for myself, and I'm somewhat ashamed to admit that my answer to that last question is a resounding "YES"
I'm not sure what this means for
HNT as part of my blog. I appreciate the concept, but not where it has led me over the past 18 months. I enjoy the opportunity to be creative, but cannot seem to let go of the competitive side. I've made some wonderful friends through
HNT and know that most of those friendships will suffer if I leave the community. It really is a difficult situation.
... or maybe I'm just
pissy because my fat, flabby belly didn't make a favorites list ...
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~